Showing posts with label Anthropology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anthropology. Show all posts

Saturday, October 20, 2012

"Magical Bloodlines" from Lilly to Dory

Hello, sister!

Firstly, I must apologize to you (and our readers) for the fact that it has been FOREVER since I last posted here.  A reasonable explanation may be that my hypothesizing *mojo*, if you will, is all being taken up by the massive quantities of writing my classes have demanded of me lately in the form of essays, article reviews, précis, research proposals, book reports, and what else have you.  Really, though, that's not an excuse, and I hereby pledge that I will do more fun hypothesizing here, because, well, it's fun!  So anyway, I just finished a five-page essay midterm in less than five hours (that's a record) and it was on the processes of genetic variation and speciation events, and naturally my mind began to do what it does best which is apply these concepts to various other nerdy things that reside in my brain.  Also, I've been kind of amazed by genetics and meiotic cell division and stuff lately, because for some reason it's hitting me now like it never did back in middle school or wherever it was I first learned about this stuff.

So yeah!  Nerdy stuff!

Basically, what got me thinking is this: when we look at human alleles (the things that carry the traits in each of our DNA, different combinations of which produce our individual gene sequences), we find that what we think of as dominant alleles, like those for curly hair, dark eyes, round blood cells, etc, are actually our oldest alleles.  Dominance, by the way, in relation to genetic traits, doesn't mean "stronger" or "better;" it simply means it masks the expression of other traits, those that we call recessive.  So anyway, our dominant alleles are our oldest ones.  Think about that.  That means all of our recessive traits (those that we inherit but whose expressions are usually masked unless we inherit them from both parents in which case we have a one-in-four chance of expressing) are the results of random mutations within the gametes (sex cells) of generations and generations and generations of ancestors.  These mutations occured one allele at a time, and were shuffled around through the recombination stage of meiotic cell division until one ended up in a fertilized embryo, and when that person was born the outside environment decided that trait (red hair, let's say) was pretty okay and allowed that individual to survive to reproductive age and pass on the mutation.  Basic stuff, I know, but pretty awesome to think about.  As my professor says, "it's all sparkly in my mind."

So anyway, back to the main idea: our dominant alleles are our oldest alleles.  K, now flip a switch in your brain and start thinking about fantasy literature.  In a lot of stories there's this concept of magical bloodlines. These bloodlines are often implied to be ancient, and to carry a sort of primordial, world-building power.  In the "Abhorsen" series, there are three; the Abhorsen, the Clayr, and the Royal Family.  All three must exist and have an heir for the world to function correctly, and the magic associated with them acts as a genetic trait.  There is often another dynamic to this idea; when two (or more) of these bloodlines are combined in one individual, it often produces interesting results.  This is a tool that the authors use in almost every story that I can think of that has these ideas of genetically acquired magic and primeval bloodlines.  For example, in "Sword of Truth" Richard is the offspring of two independently magical bloodlines, affording a unique aspect to his magic. 

Fans of "A Song of Ice and Fire" refer to a similar concept to support a popular hypothesis regarding the parentage of Jon Snow.  His character is assumed to be the offspring of two such "primordial" bloodlines, each associated with a specific type of magic that is implied to be genetic.  At least one of these bloodlines (scientifically speaking) seems to be linked with phenotypical (appearance) traits that are apparently dominant in nearly every example.  In this an other stories, an individual who inherits these magical alleles seems to always express the phenotypical traits associated with it, but an individual who inherits alleles from two of these bloodlines will usually exhibit the phenotypical traits of either one or the other, suggesting that the traits are co-dominant. 

If we apply the rules of real-world genetics, a person who inherits co-dominate genes only has a one-in-four chance of exhibiting only one of them, while their chance of exhibiting both simultaneously (appearing as a blend of both) is 50%.  A real life example of this would be blood types A and B.  A child can inherit the allele for type A from one parent and type B from the other and have a one in two chance of exhibiting type AB, because the alleles are co-dominant. That couple's children have a 1:4 chance, however, of exhibiting only type A, and the same chance for only type B. 

Going back to "Abhorsen," Lirael is another good example of this.  She does not exhibit the phenotypical traits normally associated with the Clayr (to her character's deep dismay), even though she has just as much Clayr in her as all the rest.  Since we knew from the start that Lirael had inherited at least one the world's three primordial bloodlines, and that this bloodline generally causes all of its members to express very specific phenotypical traits, the fact that she doesn't suggests that her other parent was a member of one of the other primordial bloodlines.  Just as in Richard's case, when we learned Lirael's true parentage that information served to justify her unique type of magic.  Jon Snow's case is (allegedly) similar, in that the one known primordial bloodline also carries very specific phenotypical traits.  Since he doesn't exhibit these, this (along with the series title) suggests that the other half of his alleles are co-dominantly linked to physical appearance.  Point being, in almost every example the authors seemed to decide which side of the phenotypical dice these characters would land on based on information that is not immediately available, and to suggest a Mystery™.



I find it mega interesting that these fictional worlds seem to be paralleling this concept of old alleles being dominant alleles.  Their examples are simple and somewhat skewed versions of how it works in real life (and when thought about in this context may raise a few eyebrows concerning possible eugenics implications), but make me wonder what about this idea is intriguing to us as readers.  Is it just part of human nature to equate ancientness with power?  What are your thoughts, and do you know of any other examples of this concept in literature?

Love,

Lilly


PS: I tried to make the science easy to understand while simultaneously avoiding major book spoilers.  How'd I do?

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

"The First Indo-Europeans" from Lilly to Dory

Hello, sister mine!

We've had a few conversations lately concerning the Indo-Europeans, so I'd like to share some of the things we've been discussing in class about them that you might find interesting.

But first, some overview for our readers who may not be familiar with the subject matter:

Almost all the modern European languages can be linked together linguistically, first into categorical branches, and then to a single historical common language, known as Proto-Indo-European.  Here's a diagram posted by Dory in one of our earlier posts (click for the post and a more in-depth description) that shows these connections:

It's called "Proto-Indo-European" because it's been reconstructed, based on ways of tracing the history of words (known as etymology) to find words in other languages which share a common historical root.  Because of this type of analysis, we know it has to have existed, but until recently relatively little was known about the people who actually spoke it.  However, you can tell quite a bit about a culture from its language!

First, we know through the archaeological record that the Indo-European culture originated in what is now Ukraine.  This is supported linguistically, as the modern Ukrainian language is the most similar to the reconstructed Indo-European language as compared to the other branches.

Here is where it starts getting cool, and why I love Anthro-linguistics...

We know the Indo-Euros were a pastoralist society, meaning their sustenance was based around herding some kind of animal (like sheep, cattle, goats, etc).  Typically, this "type," if you will, of culture will fall into certain patterns as far as its societal organization and spiritual beliefs.  In this case, the hierarchy follows thus: the shepherd watches over the flock as the father watches over his family (they tend to be male-dominated) as the leader watches over his tribe as a father-like deity watches over his people.  This is seen in many modern-day societies, and indeed can be spotted in the organization of Western culture and the terminology of modern Christianity (which stems from Judaism, which originated within a pastoralist group); "the good shepherd;" "sacrificial lamb;" "guide your flock;" etc.  The Indo-Euros are thought to have worshiped a god called "Sky Father," or "Diaus Pater" in it's reconstructed form, which is the root of words like "Dios" (Spanish), "Zues" (Greek), "Deu" (French), and "Dyw" (Cornish).

Now, the Indo-Euros weren't just ANY pastoralists.....

They were horse lords.

And, they had iron weapons before anyone else, making it easy for them to go around conquering all of their agrarian neighbors which is how their culture, language, and belief system spread across Europe so fast.  The blending of Indo-European and the languages of the groups they conquered is probably what kicked off the separate dialects that later evolved into the different language branches.

So, there is a certain mysterious culture that has been in Europe as long as anybody and whose language is very mysteriously indeed NOT a descendant of Proto-Indo-Euro.  They are the Basque.

My thoughts concerning this are largely centered on the idea that perhaps the ancient Basque were isolated enough to escape the notice of the conquering Indo-Euros, and so were able to keep their language where others were not.  What I'm wondering is, how did the ancient Basque live?  Were they agrarian, or were they perhaps nomadic?  This would link them to another European group who also speaks an independent language and managed to escape Indo-Euro influence: the Gypsies.

So, what are your thoughts?  Do you know something about the Basque or Gypsy cultures that would support this hypothesis, or am I completely off?

Love, Lilly

Thursday, September 15, 2011

"The momentous importance of childhood" from Lilly to Dory

Hello, sister mine!  It's been rather long since I've posted, and for that I apologize.  I've been meaning to bust out an epic piece on the subject of early humans, to incorporate some of the fragmented bits of hypotheses that have been floatin' around in my mind as of late.  I'm super excited because I've finally stumbled across the perfect article to tie it all together!

National Geographic published this article back in '06, entitled "Dikka Baby."  It's about a fossil discovery made by an Ethiopian scientist, Zeresenay Alemseged, in Africa's Great Rift Valley (a place where a goodly number of hominin fossils have been found -- our early ancestors liked to hang out there, as it's a well-sheltered and fertile river valley.  And, luckily for us future folk, tends to preserve remains quite nicely).  What's totally spectacular about this fossil is that it consists of a nearly complete Australopithecus afarensis skeleton -- that of a three year old child, dubbed the Dikka baby.



A. afarensis was one of our very early ancestors, and lived more than three MILLION years ago.  I know you're somewhat familiar with H. habilis and H. erectus on, so here's a handy timeline for reference:


The most famous example we have of A. afarensis is "Lucy," a partial skeleton found in 1974.  Much of what we know about this species comes from the largely (somewhat dubiously) reconstructed parts of Lucy's skull and body, so having a complete skeleton is fantastic.  Also, Lucy was an adult when she died, so with the Dikka baby we have some insight into what this species was like as a child.

What's particularly special about this stage in human evolution is that it marks a transition into one of our most distinct trademarks: a relatively long span of time between birth and self-sufficiency, known as the infant-dependency period.

For some background:

Primates have some of the longest infant-dependency periods of all mammals, and among primates, humans have the longest.  There are a few likely reasons for this; the foremost being our large brains.  We actually can't stay in our mothers' wombs for long enough for our brains to completely develop, because if we did our heads would be too big to fit through the birth canal!  So instead of coming out all chop-chop-ready-to-go like a baby deer, we have this period following birth in which we are totally dependent upon our mothers and the larger group so that we can mature to the point that some animals are just born at.

The Dikka baby's brain case (yes, that is a scientific term for the skull) is not quite modern human- sized, but still rather larger than a chimp's.  This is indicative of a prolonged childhood.  Now, this is where things start to get interesting.  A. afarensis was bipedal, meaning they walked on two feet.  While their upper bodies were still fairly ape-like, their hips and spine were positioned to allow upright walking, and instead of the grasping toes of their cousins, they had flatter feet and shorter toes to help propel the body forward in a walking motion.  Without grasping feet, a baby can't cling to her mother like a chimp, and so has to be carried.  This would have inhibited the mother's ability to provide for herself, and in turn caused her to depend more upon the larger group than her earlier ancestors would have.  This dependency served to strengthen family bonds, and is the predecessor to the family structure that we modern humans identify by.

Now, the reason for which humans developed bipedalism has been the subject of great speculation among anthropologists.  Some say it was to allow endurance; it expends less energy than "knuckle-walking," and while we can't move as fast as our knuckle-walking ancestors, we can go for longer distances.  Some say a higher vantage point was beneficial in the sub-Saharan grasslands where we originated.  All agree that freeing up our hands to be able to carry things was a really great idea.  But to carry what?  What could be so important for us to be able to carry that our entire physiology would rearrange itself in order to accommodate?  Well, babies of course.  But if you think about the way evolution works, this theory doesn't make much sense.  People have to reproduce in order to have babies to carry, and if they're surviving long enough to have babies then obviously their physiology isn't going to have much incentive to change.  However, try thinking about it like this: what if the only babies who are surviving are the ones whose mothers are able to carry them?  These mothers must have the inclination towards bipedalism in order to do so, and therefore their progeny are going to have a higher chance than the last generation to carry this mutation as well.  So in this way, the traits that allow bipedal walking have the advantage; it's like evolution in reverse!

Of course, no anthropological study is complete without input from the linguists.  And they have hypothesized this big-brain-induced lengthy dependency period actually prompted the development of speech itself!  Think about the way a mother coos and comforts her baby, and the way the baby makes noises in response.  Combined with the group dependency I mentioned earlier, this could very well be where the forms of communication that led to speech really got started!  I'm very interested in what you think of this model, as well.

The point all of this leads up to is really quite profound; that the very logistics of having a physically large brain are responsible for such staple human characteristics as bipedalism, social bonds, and speech, rather than our intelligence per se.  It opens up the possibility of our earlier ancestors being much much smarter than we have assumed.  All that was needed was the ability to pass on information, and the mental incentive to actually share knowledge with our peers, to point us in the direction that led to where we are today.

Monday, December 6, 2010

"Hot" from Lilly to Dory

As I sit and drink my tea, a thought pops into my head: "té." "Té" is the Irish Gaelic word for "hot," and it's pronounced exactly like the drink, or the thing you hit a golf ball off of.  I have always been puzzled as to why "té," the word itself, sounds so different from the English word, "hot."  See, I've always thought of "hot" as kind of an onomatopoeia (meaning, a word that sounds like what it is). Think about it, or say it out loud. The word itself sounds weighty, and tired. It sounds like a heavy exhale, an exasperated sigh, or exactly the kind of sound one would make while trudging along on a humid summer day in Florida.  On the other hand, "té" is quick, and sharp.  It has that same kind of abrasive sound that we English speakers like to reserve for swear words.  To a linguistic mind, these two words convey two very different messages.  But could "té" be an onomatopoeia as well?  I believe so, and this is why:

Think about where the Gaelic language originated.  It's the native language of Ireland and Scotland, and developed right alongside English but is descended from an entirely different language branch.  The climate there is cool, and damp.  It's overcast most of the year and the temperature rarely exceeds 70 degrees fahrenheit.  Why would people come up with a word like "hot," if they don't experience anything like the environment I described above?  To the contrary, think of what they do experience.  Fire, hot food, hot water, etc.  It makes much more sense to envision someone touching an object that burned them, and exclaiming "té!" as they jerk their hand away.  I think that this is a word that describes something hot to the touch, not a type of heat that surrounds you.

And I suspect that this is where the word "tea" originated, as well.



Love,
Lilly

Friday, December 3, 2010

"Fire" from Lilly to Dory

Pulled an almost all-nighter last night studying for my earth science lab final. At six o'clock this morning I was prepared to fill in all sorts of graphs and charts, calculate great circle distances between two points, and analyze detrital and chemical composition. I got to the test to find I had completely over-studied; the test consisted of five short paragraph-style questions, and I was in and out of there in less than thirty minutes.

However frustrating and largely useless, my study session (particularly the section on rocks and minerals) did serve to remind me of a hypothesis I came up with quite a while ago, while I was reading "The Kin." In the book, the characters often make and use, for practical as well as ritualistic purposes, something called a "cutter." In the anthropology world, this "cutter" is known as a projectile point: a tool formed from a rock by chipping flakes away to create a sharp edge. "Projectile point" is the broad label for any such tool, and can include knives, hand axes, spear and arrow points.



The book's characters are labeled by the author to be the earliest modern humans. Though I have found that label to be a misnomer, I have so far found them to be extremely accurate representations of Homo erectus: the direct predecessor to modern humans. This is surprising to me because this book was written in the 1920's - before the the first discovered Homo erectus skeleton had even been confirmed and there was still debate going on over whether Homo habilis was bipedal.

It's important to remember that while Homo erectus was not the first human ancestor to make "cutters," they were the first to discover how to make fire - something that truly set them apart from their earlier counterparts, Homo habilis, who did use fire when found in nature and could even store it, but couldn't make it on their own. This got me wondering: how did Homo erectus first figure out how to make fire?

There is a film from the 1970's (a sarcastically labeled, "classic" by my anthro professor) called "Quest for Fire." The film follows a group of Neanderthals as they search for a new source of fire after their precious store has been stolen by a rivaling tribe. Eventually the Neanderthals meet up with some Homo erectus who show them how to make fire by twirling a stick against a flat piece of wood. Though many anthropologists find this model laughable at best, there is no real evidence to prove fire was not first made with wood, as wood artifacts that old generally don't survive. However, something has occurred to me that seems more likely to follow the course of natural progression, and it's something that is really not all that uncommon when it comes to human discoveries: fire happened by accident.

The clue lies with the "cutter." The best rocks for making such a tool are fine-grained, as opposed to course. The majority of found projectile points are made of flint or obsidian. Both of these rock types, when fractured, break off in very neat and predictable flakes and form very sharp edges. It just so happens that the best spark-making rocks are also those with a fine grain, flint in particular. The way I see it, it was only a matter of time before a group of Homo erectus found themselves in an area rich in fine-grained rocks, sat down to make a cutter, and it made a spark.

This must have been something noticed by others as well, earlier humans included. But only Homo erectus had the brain power to make the connection, and more importantly, spread the information.

An article I read recently, titled "Fire out of Africa," hypothesizes that the discovery of fire-making gave groups of Homo erectus a revolutionary boost of confidence. Fire provides protection from predators, warmth, the ability to cook meat. It may have allowed individuals and groups to travel further than they ever had before and even may have sparked - pun intended- the African exodus itself.

. . .

Now for a related, and rather interesting factoid: there has been research done by a group of Cambridge University students concerning the relation between the development of speech in early humans and tool-making. The study involved one student silently demonstrating how to make various tool-like objects to a group of others who were to watch and then reproduce the product, all without speaking to each other. The test was to determine whether speech is required for such learning. For simpler wooden tools, such as carved wood spear points, they found no verbal communication necessary. But for stone tools, such as projectile points, they found speech to be imperative to learning the techniques. They have hypothesized that this proves that Homo habilis, the first stone-tool making early human, must have therefore had the capability of speech.

Love,
Lilly





Thursday, December 2, 2010

"Windows" from Lilly to Dory

Ok, so it all started when I was walking home from the store, and passed by this really pretty church. I noted that the reason I like it so much is probably because it reminds me a lot of the style of buildings in Mexico, with terra-cotta roof tiles, a pale yellow exterior paint, wooden doors and candelabras mounted on the walls around the outside doors and windows.

The difference, however, is that it wasn't actually structured like a hacienda-style Mexican building. A hacienda is built like a big rectangle or square, with an open central courtyard in the middle. The Hotel Caribe in my "Merida" album is a good example. 




This structure allows, of course, for very good lighting and ventilation in all the rooms. It also ensures that each room can have an opening on two opposing walls, which takes advantage of the natural pressure difference between indoors an outdoors by creating a cross-breeze. It's a pretty simple concept to figure out, even without a basic understanding of the mechanics. I use this tactic in my own apartment when it's cool out. If I only open the front windows, the breeze doesn't come in. But if I open both the front and the back windows, it creates an almost constant cross-breeze. Following so far?

So knowing that the hacienda is actually a style rooted in Spain, I wondered if the Spanish continued building this way in Mexico purely for aesthetic purposes, or was it actually suited well for the Mexican climate also (which is considerably more humid)? My first thought was to check whether this style, or something like it, is reflected in the Mayan ruins. And the answer is yes. The Palace Structure at Palenque consists of two large rectangles, each with a central courtyard in its center. Though the buildings are only one floor as opposed to three or four like the haciendas, the same practical purposes are achieved: maximum light and ventilation; opposing windows in each room creating a cross-breeze.




The interesting feature about some of the windows inside the Palace Complex is that they are not square or round but consist of two narrow slits comprised in the shape of a "T". Professor Tromans pointed out to me that the "T" shape is a symbol that represents the Mayan god of wind, so they shaped their windows into this symbol. Simple enough. Well, I think I figured out how that shape came to represent the god of wind and also why they built their actual windows this way rather than, say, simply use the symbol to decorate the outside, which seems to me to be much easier to do.

Flash back to beginning band with Mr. Elliston. When I was learning to play the flute, Elliston emphasized that high notes require you to blow air with more pressure, and low notes with less pressure (you may have been taught this as well, for the french horn). This can be achieved by making the opening in your lips smaller - for high pressure - or wider for low pressure. The difference can be felt if you blow on the back of your hand. Notice that a wider opening will blow warm air, and a smaller opening will blow cooler air.

Air moving through a smaller opening is cooler, because the air is pushed through it faster and with more pressure. You can make a very small window and the air coming through it will be cooler, kind of like air conditioning. But if you actually want a good amount of air, the window has to be bigger. So how do you achieve this? The "T" shape maximizes the capacity for air flow, while still forcing it through small openings to cool it down. Genius.




So I think that the Maya figured this out, and used it primarily for efficiency purposes. Eventually that led to the "T" symbol coming to represent wind. Not the other way around.


What do you think?

Love,
Lilly